Once, Allbirds was a “direct-to-consumer” darling. Powered by purpose and buoyed by splashy marketing, it seemed destined for greatness. Then a pesky little thing called economics got in the way, and a company once valued at $4 billion went for a fire-sale price of $39 million, relegated to the purgatory of a “brand management” firm that tries to resurrect distressed brands (like Toys“R”Us).

 

This should not shock you — at all

To grow is easy; to do so profitably is a whole different matter. A 10-year study of the S&P Global 1200 found that only one-third of companies grew at rates exceeding their cost of capital. But all of the cultural cliches, celebrity endorsements, Silicon Valley hype, and purpose signaling can be distracting. (And yes, I, too, was distracted, featuring Allbird in one too many keynotes!) But then there’s that pesky thing that plagues a good marketing tale — you need to make money!

To make money, the basics have to be right

The allure of saving the world in wool and eucalyptus shoes wore off pretty quickly for consumers. Worse, the shoes wore out even more quickly. With precarious quality, the company could not find a broad enough audience willing to support their premium-pricing model. As our research has demonstrated, a broad customer base’s buying decisions are most influenced by basics such as price, quality, and convenience; Allbirds’ grand ambitions didn’t stand a chance.

You can’t build something out of nothing

Allbirds pursued expansion with evangelical zeal: new categories, physical stores, global reach. But all of this was being built on a flimsy foundation (see “the basics have to be right”), ergo, it came crashing down. The company’s post-IPO trajectory — declining revenue, mounting losses, collapsing share price — revealed an uncomfortable truth: Scale amplified fragility. Profitable growth requires a more measured approach, and we describe it in our Forrester growth framework as a five-lever unlock.

It all comes down to value creation

Purpose may inspire, marketing may accelerate, and cultural resonance may create a halo — but economics and profitability, the former unsexy and the latter unyielding, always have the final word.

———————————————————————————————————————

Follow my research: Go to my Forrester bio and click “Follow.”

Chat with me: If you are a Forrester client interested in discussing these topics, please schedule time with me for an inquiry or a guidance session.

Plan a session: If you are a Forrester client looking to host a strategy session on a related topic, please contact your account team or email me at dchatterjee@forrester.com.