Health insurers are out of excuses. Congress has joined the growing chorus calling out the widening gap between what insurers promise and what members actually experience. Denials, delays, data breaches, and dodged questions have eroded confidence in insurers’ ability to deliver on the core promise of mitigating the financial risks of healthcare. This isn’t a messaging problem — it’s a systemic brand crisis of the industry’s own making. And it will take far more than a clever email campaign or polished commercial to fix it.

Stop Marketing Around The Problems — Fix Them

Health insurers must repair the broken processes that frustrate employers, providers, and consumers — and make trust a central brand principle. Brand isn’t a billboard or an email; it’s the sum of your total experience. It’s how your organization shows up across culture, operations, and every touchpoint in the member journey. Building loyalty and strengthening brand equity will take a sea change in how health insurers manage members’ costs, process claims, and deliver customer experiences. That begins with three imperatives:

  • Simplify. Trust starts by executing the basics: clear communication, accurate billing, timely claims, and responsive service. If these foundations are shaky, fix operations first. Skip performative value‑signaling and focus on outcomes members can see and measure. Trust has an opportunity to be earned or destroyed in every interaction. Without operational underpinnings, building trust won’t work.
  • Improve. Once the basics are sound, lead by solving the problems others avoid — especially prior authorization, claims, and care navigation. Earn your higher premiums with seamless hybrid and digital experiences that are personalized, assistive, anticipatory, and increasingly agentic. Consumers most often look for help with understanding what they paid for in the first place: their coverage and benefits. Optimizing this high‑value use case saves time and money for all stakeholders.
  • Humanize. Consumers don’t want to think about their health insurer — but when they do, the interaction needs to matter and cocreate value. Communications must be relevant, proactive updates, not generic blasts that frustrate members or end up not being read. Use real stories from members, providers, and care teams to translate complexity into human terms.

Ready To Get Started?

Remember, reputation is built on what you do, not what you say you’re going to do. The automotive, airline, and financial services industries have already proven that rebuilding trust is possible but only when companies address root‑cause experience failures, not just improve surface‑level communication.

Read our new report, Hard Truths, Harder Fixes: Why Health Insurers Must Rethink Brand, to learn from brand leaders across industries that took transformative steps to improve their brand and regain customer trust. Then read Optimize The Digital Experience For Health Insurance Members to learn how to bring this to life in the digital experience. Forrester clients can schedule a guidance session to discuss what the research means for their business and customers.

Join us in person and put these ideas into action! Register now for our CX events: CX Forums East, West, and others across the globe coming to a city near you later this year.